Skip to content

Menu

HomeAboutServicesDisclaimer
LexSage Inc. logo

Canada-U.S. Blog

Trade Lawyers Cyndee Todgham Cherniak and Susan K. Ross

Home > Canada's Federal Government > Federal Court of Canada Does Not Grant Injunction To Stop Sharing of FACTA Information

Federal Court of Canada Does Not Grant Injunction To Stop Sharing of FACTA Information

By Cyndee Todgham Cherniak on September 18, 2015
Posted in Canada's Federal Government, Constitutional Law, Legal Developments, Politics, Tax, U.S. Federal Government

Gavel and Scales of JusticeOn September 16, 2015 the Federal Court of Canada released the well written decision of the Honourable Luc Martineau in the case of Virginia Hillis and Gwendolyn Louise Deegan v. the Attorney General of Canada and the Minister of National Revenue (2015 FC 1082).  This case was brought by two American-Canadian dual citizens living in Canada who are challenging the constitutionality of FACTA (Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act) information collection and sharing.

This decision relates only to a motion for summary judgement and the granting declaratory and injunctive relief in the form of preventing the Government of Canada from sharing FACTA information with the Government of the United States. It does not address the constitutionality claims or the merits of the law.  The Court dismissed the motion of summary judgement and declined to grant declaratory and injunctive relief.

Under the intergovernmental agreement (IGA) implementing FATCA between Canada and the United States, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) will now be able to disclose to the US Internal Revenue Service (IRS) the personal bank account information of US citizens in Canada for 2014. It is expected that the information will be provided to the IRS next week on September 23, 2015.

The Honourable Luc Martineau wrote the following about judges upholding the rule of law;

“True, a great number of Canadian taxpayers holding US reportable accounts are likely to be affected by a reporting system that in many quarters is considered unjust, costly and ineffective, considering that at the end of the day they are not likely to owe taxes to the US.  In the absence of legislative provisions requiring all Canadian financial institutions (provincially and federally regulated) to automatically notify their account holders about reporting to the CRA under the IGAand Part XVIII of the ITA, these taxpayers may also be taken by surprise by any consequences that flow from such disclosure. The plaintiffs may find this deplorable, but apart from a constitutional invalidation of the impugned provisions or a change of heart by Parliament or Congress, or the governments of Canada or the US, there is nothing that this Court can judicially do today to change the situation. The impugned provisions have not been held to be ultra vires or inoperative. Judicial courage requires that judges uphold the Rule of Law.”

There are many other read-worthy quotes in this well-considered decision. This quotation has significant meaning as it is true that a Canadian judge may want to stop such information sharing with the US IRS.  This is a courageous decision based on principles.

The Federal Court of Canada did not order the plaintiffs to pay costs stating:

“This is a case where, in view of the nature of the issues and the public interest involved in clarifying the scope of novel provisions affecting hundreds of thousands of Canadian citizens, no costs should be ordered against the losing parties.”
Tags: Canada Revenue Agency, CRA, dual citizens, FACTA, Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, Hillis, IGA, information sharing, IRS, rule of law
Print:
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn
Related Posts
To GDPR or Not To GDPR - That Remains the Question !!!!
December 23, 2018
Border Searches of Electronic Devices
January 21, 2018
Tips for Traveling with Electronic Devices
October 3, 2017
Photo of Cyndee Todgham CherniakCyndee Todgham Cherniak

Cyndee Todgham Cherniak is the founding lawyer of LexSage, a boutique international trade law and sales tax firm in Toronto, Ontario. She has practiced for…

Cyndee Todgham Cherniak is the founding lawyer of LexSage, a boutique international trade law and sales tax firm in Toronto, Ontario. She has practiced for almost 20 years at Canada’s top Bay Street law firms.

Show more Show less
Photo of Su RossSu Ross

Su’s practice focuses on compliance whether dealing with cybersecurity/privacy or import/export. She deals with regulatory, civil and criminal issues. Her clients come to her for…

Su’s practice focuses on compliance whether dealing with cybersecurity/privacy or import/export. She deals with regulatory, civil and criminal issues. Her clients come to her for assistance to solve current challenges but also to identify and manage risk

Show more Show less
Photo of Heather InnesHeather Innes

Heather is a strategic negotiator and effective business communicator having worked with governments, institutions and corporations in North America, Asia, the Middle East, South America…

Heather is a strategic negotiator and effective business communicator having worked with governments, institutions and corporations in North America, Asia, the Middle East, South America, Africa and Europe.

Show more Show less

Disclaimer

This Blog/Web Site is made available by the lawyer or law firm publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this blog site you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the Blog/Web Site publisher. The Blog/Web Site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state. The postings on this Blog/Web Site should not be attributed to the authors’ respective firms. Some of the articles are posted by law students, and readers should use caution when relying on any post of a law student.
Read More....
Participating Law Schools

Topics

  • Aerospace & Defence
  • Agriculture
  • AMPs
  • Anti-Trust/Competition Law
  • Antidumping
  • audits
  • Blockchain
  • Border Security
  • Buy America
  • Canada
  • Canada's Federal Government
  • Canada-China FTA
  • Canada-EU CETA
  • Canada-Ukraine FTA
  • cannabis
  • Constitutional Law
  • Contracts
  • Controlled Goods Program
  • Corporate Counsel
  • Countermeasures
  • COVID-19
  • CPTPP
  • Criminal Law
  • Cross-border deals
  • Cross-border litigation
  • Cross-Border Real Estate
  • Cross-border trade
  • Cryptocurrencies
  • Currency Reporting
  • CUSMA
  • Customs Law
    • origin
    • tariff classification
    • valuation
  • Cybersecurity
  • Elections
  • Energy
  • Environment
  • Excise Duty
  • Excise Tax
  • Export Controls & Economic Sanctions
  • Exports
  • FCPA/Anti-Corruption
  • Food
  • Government Procurement
  • GPT
  • GST
  • GST/HST
  • Harmonization
  • HST
  • Immigration law
  • Imports Restrictions
  • Intellectual Property
  • International Arbitrations
  • Labour
  • Law Schools
  • Law Students
  • Legal Developments
    • Cybersecurity and Privacy
  • Legal Writing
  • Municipalities
  • NAFTA
    • NAFTA Renegotiations
    • USMCA
  • NAFTA 2.0
  • NAFTA Chapter 11
  • NEXUS
  • Personal Comments
  • Politics
  • Privacy
  • Proceeds of Crime/Money Laundering
  • Provincial Courts
  • Provincial Governments
  • Regulatory
  • Sales Taxes
  • Softwood Lumber
  • State Courts
  • State Governments
  • Steel
  • Supreme Court of Canada
  • tariffs
  • Tax
  • TPP-1
  • Trade Agreeements
  • Trade Remedies
    • Canada's Steel Safeguard
  • Transportation
  • Tribunals
  • U.S. Federal Government
  • U.S. Supreme Court
  • Uncategorized
  • United States
  • USMCA
  • World Trade Organization

Archives

Canada-U.S. Blog

LexSage Inc. logo
Privacy PolicyDisclaimer

About This Blog

This blog is about Canada-United States cross border legal issues. Some of the authors are practicing lawyers and some are law students. This is a forum for discussion that presents an opportunity for law students to contribute and become known to potential employers in this dynamic area of the law.

Read More...

Recent Updates

  • Don’t yet have a Safe Food for Canadians Import License? Your food imports may be stopped at the Border?
  • How We Got Port Congestion and How We Can Get Out
  • The CBSA May Take Away NEXUS If Non-Essential Travel During COVID-19 Restrictions
  • CUSMA/USMCA and the Automotive Industry: Rising Regional Value Content Requirements for Vehicles and Auto Parts
Copyright ©2025, LexSage Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Law blog design & platform by LexBlog LexBlog Logo